I apologize for the sweets, like dulce de leche and fruit preserves below. I think kids that grow up not eating sweets, given only healthier options, won't be adults who think dulce de leche is God's gift to humanity.
Something to think about to use less energy…
https://www.builditsolar.com/Projects/Cooking/cooking.htm
https://solarcooking.fandom.com/wiki/Solar_Cooking_Wiki_(Home)
https://permies.com/t/65217/DIY-Solar-Oven
I would like to try blending milk with raw cocao beans, shell intact.
Also would like to try adding cacao to coffee!
Beginner's Guide to Coffee by Ethan Chlebowski on YouTube.
A Beginner's Guide To Buying Great Coffee by James Hoffman on YouTube.
Review of above:
What’s the healthiest way to brew coffee? harvard.edu
I need to see the research before believing. Maybe a COI.
Influence of the Brewing Temperature on the Taste of Espresso, Klotz et al 2020
Of 24 participants, only 15 were able to correctly identify which of 3 cups is different, where the difference is cups with a brew temperature of 80C or 128C. 11 of 24 could identify the difference between 80C and 93C, which is statistically insignificant.
A different study on brew color:
Our systematic analysis of the color of different coffee brews yielded insights regarding an underappreciated aspect of coffee extraction. Perhaps unsurprisingly, coffee beans roasted to different colors yielded brews of different colors. More surprisingly, use of “cold” brewing temperatures (4 or 22°C) led to a beverage that was much more reddish in color than the typical brown-black color of hot (92°C) brewed coffee. Our finding that the color of the grounds is not directly translated into the brew, and that the brew color varies significantly based on brew temperature and origin, does complicate the choice of coffee and brewing parameters to achieve brewed coffee of a desired color. However, the results also offer additional opportunity for branding and marketing of cold brew, as “reddish” in color. Additionally, differential extraction of chemical species could be behind those color differences, thus, warranting the need for further research into the molecules and the physical and chemical processes that affect coffee color. Roast level and brew temperature significantly affect the color of brewed coffee, Yeager et al 2022
Overview by James Hoffmann on YouTube.
Percolation or filter brewing extracts with pure water, while the water in immersion brewing tends toward saturation with time. See reddit thread Over Extraction of Coffee is a Myth.
I'm not sure why overextracting leads to some bitterness that is unwanted. I want to suck every last essence out of coffee beans. That would be filter brewing, with water passing through compressed grounds at high pressure.
Espresso is the densest, most concentrated coffee. Water at 93C supposedly doesn't pick up the bitterness, regardless that there is a huge amount of pressure? Why wouldn't high pressure overextract the same as higher temperature?
What an engineer will think, is how much energy do the water molecules have in colliding with the coffee grounds. Temperature and pressure both affect the energy of the water molecules, right? At a molecular level, a higher temperature makes water molecules vibrate more rigorously against the grounds, the same as added pressure. The end effect would be the same: higher leaching of coffee goodness.
However, since water is mostly incompressible, the temperature increase with increase in pressure to 9 bar is negligible. For the same temperature, water properties are similar at 1 bar and 68 bar. You're hardly adding any energy at all to the water molecules in going up to 9 bar.
Thus, the magic doesn't seem to happen by the kinetic energy of the water molecules against the grounds, but instead the macroscopic efficiency in pushing water through finely ground, densely packed coffee.
Barista snobbery be damned. That said, it could be fun to take part in said snobbery. Also the satisfaction of water being completely squeezed out of a puck of coffee grounds.
While at 1 bar 100C is the maximum, at higher pressure, why not also go higher temperature? I guess the espresso machine probably likes being at a temperature that doesn't kill people.
Do these "coffee compasses" make sense?
I wonder if anyone has done double blinds in taste testing between different brew methods using the same 1:2 coffee/water ratio as espresso. Removing all grounds from the Turkish, of course.
I could get something like a Breville Bambino in the future.
See also:
https://coffeegeek.com/blog/technology/manual-vs-automatic-vs-super-auto
https://www.reddit.com/r/espresso/comments/170rnln/what_is_the_most_reliable_espresso_machine_under
https://www.thespruceeats.com/top-espresso-machines-under-100-765535
https://www.reddit.com/r/espresso/comments/v7ddhe/flair_pro_2_or_breville_bambino_which_would_you/
Automatic machines tend to break down after some years (sometimes months) of use, so maybe a hand operated espresso machine would be better.
The moka pot is the simplest “semi” espresso machine.
The Bialetti Brikka moka pot has a weighted outlet to build up more pressure for a richer coffee. Another review of the Brikka at 101coffeemachines.info. Others: YouTube1 YouTube2. https://www.schneordesign.com/diy/diy-coffee/bialetti-brikka-fix.
The new version Brikka doesn't use a weight, and instead uses a rubberish valve I dislike.
One criticism of the Moka Pot is bitter coffee from overextraction by using boiling water. Supposedly one should use 200F (93C). The research Brew temperature, at fixed brew strength and extraction, has little impact on the sensory profile of drip brew coffee, Batali et al 2020 only tried 87, 90, and 93C.
However, the brewing temperature varies with time and stays well below 93C most of the time: The secrets of the moka pot by home-barista.com. Unless using a double-valve design like the Brikka which increases pressure to about 1.5 bar.
James Hoffman says that the sputtering phase should be avoided by using the lowest heat possible and removing from heat at the start of sputtering. Another detail is to pour boiling water into the base to speed up the process…. The gist seems to be that the sputtering is superheated steam at temperatures that suck out astringents from the grounds.
“If you have a gas stove top, use a heat diffuser. It protects the pot and more importantly, prevents the coffee grounds from being scorched, and the resulting bitter taste.” channelsixtynine069 on YouTube
It's fine to try to get away with a fine grind and tamping, even on a Brikka. Reddit
Human nature wants the fanciest equipment to do something simple for an imperceptible or fantasized gain in quality. Investment in such equipment gives capitalism an orgasm: consumption for the sake of consumption. Such is the case for wine and coffee snobs.
Cold brew requires the least energy consumption. Coffee grinds soak/steep in water for 12+ hours.
I understand it's also healthier. Variables Affecting the Extraction of Antioxidants in Cold and Hot Brew Coffee: A Review, Yust, Wilkinson and Rao 2024
Flawed comparison of cold and hot brew
The experiment is flawed because they only tested 6 hours of soaking, when a minimum of 12 hours is the norm.
I wonder if using a grain mill to make coffee flour would help in extraction of antioxidants for cold brew. Likely not necessary as extra course grind is the norm for cold brew.
This study suggests that the hot brew method tends to extract additional non-deprotonated acids in comparison to the cold brew method. These acids may be responsible for the higher antioxidant activities observed in hot brew coffee samples. Additionally, the chemical composition of hot brew coffee may be more diverse and complex than that of cold brew coffee. Acidity and Antioxidant Activity of Cold Brew Coffee, Rao and Fuller 2018
I had the wrong impression that coffee ground sufficiently fine would dissolve in water. They don't. Also the course grounds are no fun to chew for added fiber.
With the manual grinder I'm currently using, all the grinds aren't exactly the same size. The finer ones add a nice texture to the liquid as it slides over the tongue. This gives me something to shoot for.
A positive to Turkish grind is that you get a very fast steep rate. If you grind the night before and leave soaking at room temperature, it's ready by the morning.
Using an overpriced consumer-oriented manual Turkish coffee grinder is too much time and work. If you want Turkish grind, I suspect a flour mill would be better.
A good electric coffee grinder has to output a bunch of different particle sizes, leading to a master-of-none situation.
A flour mill grinds with a tighter distribution size, with negligible number of particles over 300 μm. Evaluation of Flour Particle Size Distribution by Laser Diffraction, Sieve Analysis and Near-infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy, G.A. Hareland 1994 download
Unfortunately, a decent grain mill like the Mockmill starts at $340. At one point I was wondering what do Turkish people use. Turkish people mostly don't grind their own coffee. They buy Turkish grind from the store, or they go to a coffee house.
Update: Coffee Grind Size Chart, honestcoffeeguide.com
Turkish. Or using an electric kettle and pouring boiling water into a mug with a heaping tablespoon of coffee grounds. Least wait and least amount of stuff to wash after. I filter the grounds with my teeth like a real man.
Freeze dried is supposedly better than spray dried, which is a process using heat. Great for milk drinks.
Boiling water supposedly burns the flavor, so mix in a little cold water first.
This person sought to find the best storage method for coffee: room temperature, refrigerated, or frozen. However, plastic was used for storage. Plastic is vapor permeable.
An Experiment in Coffee Storage, janneinosaka.com 2008
1 liter of whole milk
1 tablespoons of stevia / erythritol mixture
1 tablespoon of sugar
100 ml of cream (optional)
1 vanilla stick or vanilla extract (optional)
1 teaspoon baking soda (optional)
10 grams of unflavored gelatin (optional)
Really, you only need milk and sugar. That's it. I like my dulce de leche more creamy, so I add cream.
Sweeteners can be added to taste. I find any store bought dulce de leche overly sweet. They add as much as 1/2 ratio of sugar/milk. Practically ruins the experience.
Erythritol crystals melt at 121 degrees celcius, but do not reduce (chemistry).
Gelatin is to make the dulce de leche denser with a shorter cooking time. It's cheating and not necessary.
Baking soda helps reduce lumps in the dulce de leche. Some recipes have it, but I am suspicious of this ingredient on the end outcome.
OVEN ATTEMPTS:
I have attempted using an oven to make dulce de leche, because I thought heat is more evenly distributed, and will keep the mixture from burning on the bottom of the pot. Milk has a boiling point of 95 degrees celcius, however, you can set the oven slightly above this temperature. Maybe an infrared thermometer would help to check the temperature of the milk surface.
As opposed to an oven, cooking with a pot on top of a flame can superheat the milk adjacent to pot surface, causing it to boil over and spill from the pot. The bottom of the pot in an oven is unlikely to reach such a high temperature as that of a flame.
In an oven, the top surface of the milk is at more of a danger of burning from the top coil of the oven, from radiative heat transfer.
Also, if you set the oven temperature too high, the fat will separate, or perhaps break down, and you won't get a creamy mixture: just runny oil with chunky parts.
For some reason, it takes FOREVER in the oven. More than 5 hours. Is the moisture not allowed to escape, thus keeping the water in the milk from evaporating?
NORMAL INSTRUCTIONS:
Place milk, cream, and sugar, and the optional vanilla, in a stovetop pan, and bring to 90 C.
At 90 C, you can optionally add baking soda, and optionally add gelatin.
Stir every so often. You will require progressively more stirring as the milk thickens. You can also turn down the temperature as it thickens to reduce a temperature gradient between the surface and the inside of the dulce de leche. Some people add marbles to encourage self mixing, and perhaps they also create a surface at a higher temperature than the surrounding dulce de leche. I suspect that commercial production of dulce de leche involves ovens with automatic mixing.
Raw milk and milk cream, stirred with powdered milk to thicken, sweetened with stevia and erythritol. Alternatively start with evaporated milk as a base. Not because it tastes better, but because male cooking means less effort.
Raw milk 60ml
Milk cream 20ml
Powdered milk 100g
10 drops of stevia
Full instructions for making raw milk yogurt at:
https://nourishedkitchen.com/raw-milk-yogurt
I'm going to try adding culture to yoghurt at room temperature, rather than 110F (43C) as suggested. Or maybe I'll use my oven.
Which bacterial culture should I buy?
Fresh milk, even if refrigerated, starts to turn sour within 2-3 days. Could you preserve milk by having it turn to yogurt instead?
Update: found these articles:
MESOPHILIC YOGURT: MAKING YOGURT AT ROOM TEMPERATURE, Ashley Adamant 2021
How To Activate Your New Mesophilic Yogurt Culture, positivelyprobiotic.com
If one were to genetically engineer yogurt bacteria that proliferated at 4 degrees Celsius, you could put some in fresh cow milk and place the milk in the fridge. Instead of having refrigerated milk go bad if it isn't consumed within the first few days, you would have sour flavored yogurt.
This isn't a how-to, rather some research notes. The conclusion at the moment is that making yogurt from milk at 4C would require a special yogurt bacterial strain that could outcompete other bacteria at 4C. The same way the normal yogurt strain can outcompete other bacteria at 43C.
Yogurt is stored in the fridge after it reaches maturity. Otherwise it goes sour. See: https://www.quora.com/How-did-one-store-yogurt-or-curd-before-the-invention-of-the-modern-refrigerator
The longer yogurt ferments the less lactose remains and the lower the pH the yogurt will have. This has the effect of making yogurt taste sour and may cause it to separate between curds and whey. Unless there is mold growth or other signs of spoilage it is safe to consume over fermented yogurt. … As the milk continues to acidify the proteins begin to disassociate with whey in the milk, a process called Syneresis. This causes it to separate into curds and whey. By draining this whey off the yogurt becomes thicker, more like cheese which will last longer in unrefrigerated conditions. urbanfermentation.com
So it would still be possible to drink yogurt that passed its optimal taste. But how do you know when not to drink it? “Whey typically runs clear, so if that water on top of your yogurt is looking a little cloudy, better play it safe and toss it out.” tastingtable.com
4 degrees celsius is the maximum temperature recommended for refrigerators. Would it be good to genetically engineer a yogurt culture that proliferates at 4C? This could extend the life of the milk as yogurt, with no heat and minimal effort. The idea is to add the culture right after opening the milk carton, or milking from the cow, and it would slowly become yoghurt. Raw milk would then still be healthy past 2-3 days.
The purpose of boiling is to kill unwanted microbes, but milk from a carton or straight from a healthy cow should be relatively free of microbes? According to the nourishedkitchen.com article above, raw milk has some naturally occurring non-harmful bacteria. In order to maintain a consistent taste, they will keep you using fresh starter culture for each batch of yogurt rather than reusing the resulting yogurt as a starter.
Regular yoghurt bacteria will not be active at 4 degrees Celsius.
Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus:
“ The optimum temperature and pH conditions for lactobacilli growth are 30–40 °C and 5.5–6.2, respectively; however, the Lactobacillus genus is diversified and belonging bacteria can grow in temperature ranging from 2 to 53 °C. ”. Growth Kinetics of Probiotic Lactobacillus Strains in the Alternative, Cost-Efficient Semi-Solid Fermentation Medium, Śliżewska and Chlebicz-Wójcik 2020
“ The optimum growth temperature for lactobacilli lies between 30 and 40°C but they can grow at temperatures ranging from as low as 5°C to an upper limit of 53°C, depending on the species. ”
Streptococcus thermophilus:
“ Because those organisms grow over different temperatures ranges, the term ‘cold’ can be used with respect to their behavior only in a relative sense, with reference to the minimum temperature for growth of each organism. Although a defining minimum temperature is often given for each group-40, 5, and <0°C for thermophiles, mesophiles, and psychrotrophs, respectively (3)-the minimum temperatures for growth of individual organisms within each group vary widely. ” Microbial Control with Cold Temperatures, Colin Gill 2001
In this study, fresh milk was used as a raw material and Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus were used as fermentation strains to yield yogurt at different fermentation temperatures (30, 37, 40, 42, and 45 ◦C).
…
The yogurt fermented at 30 ◦C had the lowest essential amino acid content, the lowest water-holding capacity and hardness, and low acid and bitterness values. It can be used as an ingredient to be fortifed with proteins, amino acids, and other nutrients to prepare fermented yogurt beverages, since it is not suitable for con- sumption as solidifed yogurt. The yogurt fermented at 37 ◦C had the highest essential amino acid content, and the highest hardness, viscos- ity, and elasticity. SEM images show that a dense network structure was formed at 37 ◦C; however, the bitterness value was the highest. This yogurt can be supplemented with sweeteners, minerals, vitamins, and other nutrients to prepare solidifed yogurt. The yogurt fermented at 40 ◦C had the highest water holding capacity, as well as the highest values for hardness, adhesiveness, sweetness, and acidity. This yogurt can be made into a frm yogurt, which is rich in nutrition. The amino acid and MUFA content in the yogurt fermented at 42 ◦C was the highest. SEM images show that a dense network structure was formed at 42 ◦C. The yogurt fermented at this temperature was found to be nutritious, easy to digest and absorb, moderate in bitterness and astringency, and low in acidity and sweetness, all of which are suitable for infants and young adults. The yogurt fermented at 45 ◦C had the highest PUFA content. However, its viscosity, elasticity, and chewiness were the worst, the sourness value was high, and the taste and sweetness were the lowest. Fermentation temperature affects yogurt quality: A metabolomics study, Yang et al 2021
From Wikipedia: “Yogurt made with raw milk can be contaminated with bacteria that can cause significant illness and death, including Listeria, Cryptosporidium, Campylobacter, Brucella, Escherichia coli and Salmonella.[41] Yogurts can also be contaminated with aflatoxin-producing Aspergillus flavus, Aspergillus parasiticus and Aspergillus nomius.”
Proliferation capacity of unwanted microbes at 0-4 Celsius:
Growth of Listeria monocytogenes at refrigeration temperatures, Walker et al 1990
Ingredients: fruit, thickener, stevia leaves.
Optional: citrus (lemon, etc), cloves, cinnamon, etc.
Cut fruit into chunks so the fruit juice can easily come out. For strawberries , slicing in half is sufficient. No need to remove the strawberry leaves as they are edible and healthy.
Put fruit into pot with stevia leaves and some tablespoons of water to cover bottom surface of pot. Apply medium heat and stir until it starts to look like lumpy soup. Do not overcook so fruit maintains its color. The goal is for some of the fruit juice to extract so it can mix with the thickener.
Lower heat to simmer and mix in thickener, like pectin or chuño. I only have experience with chuño. Keep stirring in additional thickener until fruit juice doesn't run on spoon. Turn off the heat. The fruit juice will thicken further upon cooling.
Before cooling, pour preserves into a sterilized glass jar until full. Seal with lid. Upon cooling, a proper lid will make an airtight seal.
The thickener, and optionally citric acid, will protect the preserves for at most a week after opening the sealed jar. The sealed jar will keep for close to a year, though I wouldn't know because I consume within 3 months.
6 Brilliant Ways to Open Stubborn Jars, Marinelli on tasteofhome.com
I think even the healthier option oils are not healthy to consume. So an ideal diet would not have oil. Unfortunately, I live among families that are going to continue to use oil.
I have in memory that certain oils are healthier, such as first cold pressed olive oil with low acidity content. Also relatively healthy are coconut oil, avocado oil, almond oil, etc. These also happen to be relatively expensive.
I reserve this space to compilate research on healthier oil options, and where they fit in a diet, if at all.
Should You Refrigerate Your Cooking Oils? Cat Perry cleaneatingmag.com 2021
Discussion